Rational Religion?

  (08 October 08)
  by Greg Spearritt

Is this what rational religion looks like? Or must we dispense with church and religion altogether to achieve rationality, as John Gunson proposes?

2 comments

all u people are stupid

Posted by jim mooskeller

David Miller comments, 1st January 2009:

I find myself in sympathy with many of John Gunson’s viewpoints. But not all of them. I do have some quibbles. Here is one:-

John is claiming that we are secular people rather than religious people. It seems to me that John is conflating ‘religion’ and the ‘supernatural’. In this he is in good company. Such confusion is normal within our everyday language. The two words have almost become synonymous. I suggest that we begin the attempt to be more precise. Even if our attempts lead us in different directions, it will at least be illuminating.

To start with, I wish to assert that religion is not necessarily supernatural. That supernaturalism is not the basis of religion. Let me start by asserting that we do not worship a religion. We worship the gods. Via religions we worship the gods. Religion is our means of worshipping our gods. Via the means of religion we worship our gods. Religion is our tool, our method of worship.

Admittedly, historically, the gods have usually been portrayed as possessing supernatural powers. Yet God and the gods are merely symbols for our ‘greatest principles’. These symbols are usually metaphorical personifications with supernatural powers added on. Religions have been contaminated by this association with the supernatural for tens of thousands of years. Hence the ‘common usage’ we usually find in our dictionaries. That is, unless you find one, like the Macquarie, that includes within its list of definitions – “the quest for the values of the ideal life”.

I wish to claim that religion is, at base, the worship of our greatest principles. In an attempt to remove the supernaturalist baggage we could, instead, say that religion is the ‘revering’ of our greatest principles. Or better still – Religion is the means we utilize to ‘venerate’ our greatest principles. Put the other way round – If we wish to venerate our greatest principles, we find an appropriate religion with which to do so.

What constitutes a religion? Let us begin to look at some of the requirements :-
Firstly, as already mentioned, the reverence and veneration of our greatest principles.
Secondly, the apprehension and realization of our greatest principles. In simpler words, getting to know and understand them.
Thirdly, the manifestation and actualization of our greatest principles. In simpler words, bringing them into being in our world, both in ourselves as well as in others.

So, if our greatest principles involve no supernatural elements, then our means of venerating them, our religions, need no supernatural methods either. “Okay so far, but what are these greatest principles?” I hear you asking. Let us try to answer this question.

(As yet I have managed to tease out four categories of ‘greatest principles’. But aspects of them often overlap and sometimes conflict).
1. Our highest values - e.g. Goodness, truth, beauty.
2. Our loftiest ideals – e.g. Love, compassion, mercy, justice, freedom, creativity, etc.
3. Our peak experiences – e.g. Wonder, awe, mystery, oneness, uniqueness, interconnectedness, etc.
4. Our areas of ultimate concern – e.g. Self, family, community, nation, humanity, nature, planet, universe, etc.
As you can see, all completely natural. Nothing supernatural about any of them.

So, in conclusion, I hope that I have shown that there is a sense in which I can refute John Gunson’s claim that we are secular people and not religious people. In my terms, we are both secular and religious. Nevertheless, I agree with him that, in my words, some of us have managed to drop our supernaturalist baggage.



Posted by David Miller

Leave your own comment...

Name:
Email:
Comment:
Security Code:


Search Site

Contact Us!

14 Richardson St
Lane Cove
NSW   2066
AUSTRALIA

sofnetwork@gmail.com

www.sof-in-australia.org