Crossan, John Dominic - How to Read the Bible and Still Be a Christian

  (26 July 18)

How to Read the Bible and Still be a Christian


John Dominic Crossan How to Read the Bible and Still be a Christian



A review by Rodney Eivers
(Reviewed July 2018)

The Bible teaches us how to be kind and loving people. Right?  Those of us brought up from childhood as churchgoers and people of Christian faith take this for granted. Millions upon millions of Bibles are given away or sold at concession prices every year by such institutions as the Bible Societies, and Gideon’s.

The assumption is that if only people would read the Bible they will become good people by following the examples set by the stories within.

But is this necessarily so? John Dominic Crossan suggests that we read the Bible in “full”.  If we do this we find that the scriptures send very mixed messages indeed.  This applies right from Genesis to Revelation.  What would a perceptive reader coming in objectively to read the Bible without a background of religious faith find?  In taking the writing at face value she would find that the non-violence proclaimed initially as the characteristic of God and Jesus falls away in due course to recourse to power and aggression.

Crossan sees this pattern occurring from the stories of the  Garden of Eden, right through the period of the kings and prophets to the gospels and on to the writings attributed to Paul.

He explains this duality through the changing context (his preferred term for this is “matrix”) of the times at which the various books of the bible came to be written. Through my 70 years or so of Bible study I was aware of this and allow for it but John Crossan brings new emphasis and new clarity.  His recognised reputation as arguably the most acclaimed biblical scholar of this generation comes through in his historical referencing. The bonus is that in this instance, at least, his writing is very readable.

Crossan’s description and analysis of the setting of the Jesus story and the writings of Paul in that first turbulent century of the Common Era would be a clear as any I have studied. It matches well other insights I have had recently into the link between, the developing Christian theology of that period, Greek philosophical thought and the divine political status of the Roman emperor.

Crossan describes the see-sawing in Biblical thrust as between distributive justice (the loving side of God and Jesus) and retributive justice (the violent, vengeful side of God and Jesus).  He makes a big thing of the Bible and its story about justice.  Some would argue that justice requires vengeance – we see this in the newspapers and TV every day.

The author, however, makes this plea:

Justice is the body of love and love is the soul of justice…We have separated what cannot be separated if each term is to retain its full power.  Justice without love may end in brutality, but love without justice must end in banality. Love empowers justice and justice embodies love. Keep both or get neither.

So let us read the Bible in full. But let us indeed be selective  in what we take from it. In observing that swing between goodwill and violence to be found there,  may we extract,  from the context,  the message of justice with love. The responsibility to do so lies within our personal faith  convictions as well as with the decision-making councils of mainline churches.

A couple of footnotes:

  1. “For The Love of God – How the Church is Better and Worse than you ever imagined”. – There has been some recognition recently of the mixed messages on violence promoted by Christians over the centuries in this informative documentary produced this year (2018) by the Centre of Public Christianity. It is recommended viewing
  2. Some, like me, would initially reject the description of Jesus in the Bible as violent and vengeful. For those claiming to be “Biblical Christians”, however, John Crossan and I would recommend that you read the Book of Revelation in full.


Leave your own comment...

Security Code:

Search Site

Contact Us!

14 Richardson St
Lane Cove
NSW   2066